Ever wondered why it’s almost always a diamond when someone pops the question? The tradition of diamond engagement rings has become so ingrained in our culture that few of us stop to ask how it started or why it persists. As someone who’s helped friends choose the perfect ring and even written extensively about symbolism in jewellery, I’ve seen first-hand how powerful and emotional this tradition can be. But there’s a fascinating story behind it—one that blends clever marketing, social trends, historical shifts, and deep emotional resonance.

Let’s dig into why diamonds came to symbolise a lifelong promise—and whether that still holds true today.

The Origin: A Strategic Sparkle

While ancient Romans are thought to have used betrothal rings as early as the 2nd century BCE, diamonds weren’t always the centrepiece. In fact, diamonds didn’t enter the engagement ring scene until the late 1400s.

The first recorded diamond engagement ring was given by Archduke Maximilian of Austria to Mary of Burgundy in 1477. This was more of a political alliance than a romantic gesture, but it set a royal precedent. Even so, diamonds remained a rarity in engagement rings for centuries.

De Beers and the Marketing Masterstroke

If there’s one company responsible for making diamonds the engagement standard, it’s De Beers.

In the late 1930s, De Beers launched an advertising campaign in the United States with a now-legendary slogan: “A Diamond is Forever.” The campaign reframed diamonds not as rare geological artefacts, but as indispensable tokens of eternal love. By linking diamonds to emotion and social expectation, De Beers created a cultural shift that still resonates today.

According to a study by Stanford Graduate School of Business, De Beers’ marketing led to an increase from 10% to over 80% of engagement rings featuring diamonds by the 1990s.

The strategy worked because it tapped into a psychological truth: people want their love to be seen as eternal, valuable, and unique. And diamonds, with their durability and sparkle, offer a physical metaphor for that.

The Symbolism of Diamonds

1. Durability
Diamonds are the hardest naturally occurring substance on Earth. What better way to symbolise enduring love?

2. Clarity
A clear diamond reflects purity and honesty—qualities any relationship aspires to.

3. Rarity
Though not as rare as marketing would have you believe, diamonds still hold a certain prestige. They’re a luxury many aspire to.

4. Sparkle (Brilliance)
That eye-catching glitter is not just aesthetic—it represents joy, light, and celebration.

Social Pressures and Expectations

Let’s be honest—some of us buy diamond rings because we feel we should. I remember helping a friend pick out a ring and watching him feel torn between what he could afford and what he thought his partner (and her family) expected.

In many cultures, diamond rings have become a social signal. They suggest commitment, financial stability, and adherence to tradition. Even in modern relationships that challenge gender roles or heteronormative norms, the diamond ring often endures.

Are Diamonds Actually Rare?

Not really. While high-quality, flawless diamonds are less common, the truth is that the industry tightly controls supply to maintain the illusion of rarity.

“The value of diamonds has always been more about perception than scarcity,” says gemmologist Dr. Lisa Turner. “Most people don’t realise how strategically the diamond market is regulated.”

Alternative Stones and Modern Shifts

Trends are shifting. More couples are opting for sapphires, emeralds, moissanite, or even lab-grown diamonds, which are nearly identical in composition but far more ethical and budget-friendly.

I recently interviewed a couple who chose a vintage opal ring for their engagement. “It felt more us,” the bride-to-be told me. “Neither of us connects with the whole diamond thing, and I wanted something that told our story.”

This shift reflects a broader cultural move towards personalisation and authenticity. People want their rings to be about their values—not just marketing messages.

Psychological and Emotional Weight

There’s a kind of emotional gravity that comes with a diamond ring. It’s not just the sparkle or the cost—it’s the moment, the symbolism, the intent. But here’s the catch: that weight doesn’t necessarily require a diamond. What matters is the meaning you attach to it.

And sometimes, the expectation itself can lead to pressure, disappointment, or debt. In fact, a 2019 study by The Knot found that the average cost of an engagement ring in the UK is around £1,900—though many spend far more due to societal pressure.

Practical Considerations

Durability: Diamonds are ideal for daily wear—perfect for something that’s meant to be worn forever.

Maintenance: Diamonds are relatively low-maintenance but do require cleaning to maintain brilliance.

Resale Value: Contrary to popular belief, most diamonds lose value after purchase unless they are particularly rare or part of a designer collection.

FAQs: Quick Answers for Curious Minds

Q: When did diamonds become popular in engagement rings?
A: Around the 1940s, largely due to De Beers’ “A Diamond is Forever” campaign.

Q: Are lab-grown diamonds real?
A: Yes, they are chemically and physically identical to natural diamonds.

Q: Do I have to buy a diamond for an engagement ring?
A: Absolutely not. The best ring is one that fits your story, values, and budget.

Q: What are good alternatives to diamonds?
A: Moissanite, sapphires, emeralds, rubies, and even vintage rings offer stunning alternatives.

Q: Do diamonds increase in value?
A: Typically, no. Most lose resale value unless exceptionally rare.

Final Thoughts: What Really Matters

So, why do engagement rings have diamonds? Because tradition, marketing, symbolism, and social norms all aligned to make them the norm. But that doesn’t mean they’re the only—or best—choice.

The most meaningful engagement ring is the one that tells your story, fits your values, and represents your unique relationship.

Have you ever considered a non-diamond ring? Or maybe you have a story about choosing the perfect one? I’d love to hear it—drop a comment or share your experience below.

You may also want to know that why sapphires comes in different colors.

If you want to learn more about gemstones then make sure to visit our homepage.